I figure if “Wicked’s” director, Jon M. Chu, can divide a Broadway musical into two parts, then I can divide my critique of the first part into two blogs. This part addresses my problems with the production.
Granted, I enjoyed it. Didn’t even think about leaving in the middle for a bathroom break. At the same time, I thought making the first half the same length as the original Broadway production was unnecessary. To do this, the director added various subplots that really didn’t advance the story; they just doubled down on it.
Cases in point.
The scene where Ariana Grande sings “Popular” to Elphaba. It’s one of the most emulated songs in the story, but this version is so over the top that you miss the irony of it. It’s all Ariana Grande pulling out clothing and shoes, swimming around Elphaba’s bed as a dolphin for some purpose, and then not focusing on Elphaba’s retreat in a way that shows her green discomfort.
Then there’s the scene where Elphaba and Glinda are in Oz and about to meet the Wizard. But first there is an extraneous explanation about a book called the Grimmerie, which is the source of all wizardry. It includes a cameo appearance by the original cast members Edina Menzel and Kristen Chenowith in something totally unnecessary. And insulting from my point of view.
Finally, at the end of Part I Elphaba sings the anthem “Defying Gravity.” In the Broadway production she sings it alone, but in Chu’s version she’s accompanied by a myriad of flying monkeys who just got their wings. Oh, how to diminish a signature song with special effects.
Having seen the theater version, I know the second act is much darker. Yet there are several musical ensemble numbers that could overshadow the real story. They almost do in the stage production. I predict they will in the film. And the pity is that the wonderful questions about what is good and what is evil will take a back seat when they are the real content.
I’m giving my experience with “Wicked, Part I” a thumbs up, even though I have issues. Those who never saw the Broadway production or read the original Wicked novel will have a wonderful time. Who am I to dissuade them?
Leave a Reply