As a child, I learned about the Battle of Little Bighorn; only it was more commonly referred to as Custer’s Last Stand. Custer himself was portrayed as an American military hero who was unjustly annihilated by a group of several Indian tribes who banded together in Montana to fight the U.S. Army.
Fast forward to present day: Today Earl and I spent eight hours exploring the actual battlefield and learning what happened. It’s true Custer and his 210 men were annihilated on June 25, 1876; but to say it was “unjust” is, in itself, unjust.
After listening to park rangers, viewing a video, taking a guided tour, and walking the actual terrain of the Little Bighorn Battlefield, I think I have at least a primitive understanding of the historical situation. In a nutshell, it was a clash of cultures.
By various governmental decrees, the Great Plains Indian tribes had been relegated to reservations and a way of life that was markedly different from what they knew. Some of the Indians abided by the decrees (or treaties) while others did not. It really didn’t matter, because the United States Government didn’t adhere to their own treaties. For example, when gold was discovered in the Black Hills on the Indian reservation in South Dakota, our country allowed panhandlers and settlers to invade the lands we’d earlier given to the Indians. This ultimately led to an amassing of several tribes of Indians in the Little Bighorn Region just off the reservation. These Indians felt their spiritual home had been invaded.
Enter the U.S. Army, which was ordered to bring the Indians back to the reservation. Lt. Colonel George Armstrong Custer was part of this contingent, although not its first in command. It’s a long, convoluted story of generals, lower ranking officers, lack of communication, and misunderstanding of the number of Indians involved that lead to Custer’s defeat. But was it unjust? I don’t think so.
Basically, Custer was to have waited for additional troops to arrive on June 26, the day after the massacre. He did not follow orders but attacked a superior force of Indians on June 25. At that time, he also split his men into three groups and sent two of them to other parts of the battlefield. They were beyond his help, when he needed them. Yet, had he waited for the other troops to arrive on June 26, history might have told a different tale.
Either way, it seems to me that the Indians were the ones who were treated unjustly in terms of treaties and treatment, and they seized the moment to retaliate. Custer was merely in the wrong place at the wrong time.
After leaving Little Bighorn Battlefield, we went to eat at the Purple Cow, an establishment touted by our Fodor’s guidebook. We saw the sign from the highway, but when we arrived we learned the Purple Cow had gone out of business and was replaced by a Chinese buffet. I think we felt a little like Custer, expecting one thing and experiencing another. Someone should tell Fodor’s.